sbell
Country/State : Canada Age : 49 Joined : 2013-11-06 Posts : 1423
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series Wed May 03, 2017 12:21 am | |
| Honestly, you could call it whatever you want. In terms of shape it is more like Diadectes anyway.
While using Panini as a jumping point is useful for the sort-of generic figures, they were produced far later and wouldn't include the same animals.
As for conflating Camptosaurus with Parasaurolophus, given that they are kind of unrelated ornithopods (iguanodont vs hadrosaur) and one has a distinct crest, while the other has thumb spikes, I would not recommend it.
The assignment of the Pachycephalosaurus and Maiasaura would also be shaky, as those figures are pretty theropod-like. Which is what was tricky about them. Don't even get started on counting fingers and toes...
I'm also surprised that there aren't more of the sea creatures aren't pictured--I sent Beatrice a set of 8 when I sent here...a lot! _________________ I used to have an online store, but now it's a Blog exploring the variety in my collection! Fauna Figures Toys & Collectables [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]I'm also a big freshwater fish-figure fan. Know of anything new and exciting? I need to know as well! |
|
Roger Admin
Country/State : Portugal Age : 50 Joined : 2010-08-20 Posts : 35848
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series Wed May 03, 2017 4:58 am | |
| - sbell wrote:
- Honestly, you could call it whatever you want. In terms of shape it is more like Diadectes anyway.
While using Panini as a jumping point is useful for the sort-of generic figures, they were produced far later and wouldn't include the same animals.
As for conflating Camptosaurus with Parasaurolophus, given that they are kind of unrelated ornithopods (iguanodont vs hadrosaur) and one has a distinct crest, while the other has thumb spikes, I would not recommend it.
The assignment of the Pachycephalosaurus and Maiasaura would also be shaky, as those figures are pretty theropod-like. Which is what was tricky about them. Don't even get started on counting fingers and toes...
I'm also surprised that there aren't more of the sea creatures aren't pictured--I sent Beatrice a set of 8 when I sent here...a lot! Beatrice will surely enter these figures on TAI later. She has an impressive contribution to te wiki and his collection is quite huge and she is taking new pictures of all her figures. About your identifications, I am not questioning them. I trust more in you than in what these chubby figures intend to represent. The problem, is that often figures are marketed not exactly according with what is being represented and I've found it incredible how similar is this set when compared with Panini's. I am not talking about individual models but as a group of animals. Conflating is my favorite personal sports, so don't get shocked if I call edmontonia to an edmontosaurus or brontotherium to a brontosaurus. This is not definitively my cup of tea and I am very thankful to you regarding this subject. So, before your last post, I changed some of them but if you think these work better the other way, I rename it back. Arsinotherium, now Coelodonta Diadectes now cynognatus Edmontonia now Polacanthus Maiasaura now Iguanodon Megatherium now Moropus Mosasaurus now Tylosaurus Saichania now Palaeoscincus |
|
sbell
Country/State : Canada Age : 49 Joined : 2013-11-06 Posts : 1423
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series Wed May 03, 2017 8:22 am | |
| - Roger wrote:
- sbell wrote:
- Honestly, you could call it whatever you want. In terms of shape it is more like Diadectes anyway.
While using Panini as a jumping point is useful for the sort-of generic figures, they were produced far later and wouldn't include the same animals.
As for conflating Camptosaurus with Parasaurolophus, given that they are kind of unrelated ornithopods (iguanodont vs hadrosaur) and one has a distinct crest, while the other has thumb spikes, I would not recommend it.
The assignment of the Pachycephalosaurus and Maiasaura would also be shaky, as those figures are pretty theropod-like. Which is what was tricky about them. Don't even get started on counting fingers and toes...
I'm also surprised that there aren't more of the sea creatures aren't pictured--I sent Beatrice a set of 8 when I sent here...a lot! Beatrice will surely enter these figures on TAI later. She has an impressive contribution to te wiki and his collection is quite huge and she is taking new pictures of all her figures. About your identifications, I am not questioning them. I trust more in you than in what these chubby figures intend to represent. The problem, is that often figures are marketed not exactly according with what is being represented and I've found it incredible how similar is this set when compared with Panini's. I am not talking about individual models but as a group of animals. Conflating is my favorite personal sports, so don't get shocked if I call edmontonia to an edmontosaurus or brontotherium to a brontosaurus. This is not definitively my cup of tea and I am very thankful to you regarding this subject. So, before your last post, I changed some of them but if you think these work better the other way, I rename it back. Arsinotherium, now Coelodonta Diadectes now cynognatus Edmontonia now Polacanthus Maiasaura now Iguanodon Megatherium now Moropus Mosasaurus now Tylosaurus Saichania now Palaeoscincus
I think those can work. Still don't like the little blue one as a cynodont of any kind...still looks more like a diadectimorph that anything else. But, yes, they are pretty generic overall...! _________________ I used to have an online store, but now it's a Blog exploring the variety in my collection! Fauna Figures Toys & Collectables [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]I'm also a big freshwater fish-figure fan. Know of anything new and exciting? I need to know as well! |
|
Bowhead Whale
Country/State : Canada Age : 47 Joined : 2012-02-01 Posts : 2637
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series Fri May 05, 2017 2:22 am | |
| Those tiny figures are cute! |
|
SUSANNE Admin
Country/State : Denmark, the peninsula of Djursland. Age : 72 Joined : 2010-10-01 Posts : 37808
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series Fri May 05, 2017 2:49 am | |
| SO great that this topic was brought forward again They are so lovely |
|
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: K&M Mini Series | |
| |
|